Home Appraisals vs. Home Inspections: What Every Homebuyer Needs to Know

When you're buying a home, two critical assessments stand between you and closing day: the home appraisal and the home inspection. While these terms are often used interchangeably, they serve entirely different purposes in the homebuying process. Understanding the distinction between them can help you make informed decisions, avoid costly surprises, and navigate your home purchase with confidence.

The Key Difference: Value vs. Condition

At their core, home appraisals and home inspections answer two fundamentally different questions:

Home Appraisal: "What is this property worth?"

Home Inspection: "What is the condition of this property?"

A home appraisal determines the fair market value of a property, primarily to protect the lender's collateral. A home inspection evaluates the physical condition of the home's structure and systems, primarily to protect you, the buyer.

What is a Home Appraisal?

A home appraisal is a professional assessment of a property's fair market value, conducted by an independent licensed or certified appraiser. The appraiser's job is to provide an unbiased opinion of what the home is worth in the current market.

Who Orders and Pays for the Appraisal?

The mortgage lender typically orders the appraisal, but the buyer pays for it as part of their closing costs. This arrangement ensures impartiality—federal regulations stemming from the 2008 financial crisis mandate that appraisers be hired through third-party management companies to prevent conflicts of interest. Neither the buyer, seller, nor lender can influence the appraisal process in order to ensure an accurate fair market value of the property.

According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, buyers have the right to receive a free copy of all appraisals and other written valuations for first-lien and certain higher-priced mortgage loans. Lenders must provide these copies promptly, or at least three days before closing.

What Does an Appraiser Evaluate?

During an appraisal, the appraiser will:

• Examine the property's physical characteristics: This includes the size of the property and home (square footage), number of bedrooms and bathrooms, overall condition, quality of construction and materials, and any special features or amenities (pool, solar panels, recent renovations)
  
  
• Assess the location: Proximity to schools, shopping, and transportation; neighborhood characteristics and desirability; any negative factors (busy roads, power lines, commercial zoning nearby)
  
  
• Compare to similar properties: The appraiser analyzes recent sales of comparable homes ("comps") in the area, typically within the past 6-12 months and in close proximity to the subject property
  
  

The appraiser compiles their findings into a detailed appraisal report that includes the property's estimated market value and supporting data for that valuation.

How Much Does an Appraisal Cost?

Home appraisal costs vary based on several factors, but you can generally expect to pay:

• Single-family homes: $300-$550 on average 
• Condos: $400-$750
• Multi-family homes: $600-$1,500
• Government-backed loans (FHA, VA, USDA): $400-$900+

Costs can be higher in areas with higher costs of living, for larger or more complex properties, in remote locations requiring extra travel time, or when unique features require specialized knowledge.

Why Appraisals Matter

For Lenders: The appraisal protects the lender by ensuring they don't lend more than the property is worth. If you default on the mortgage, the lender needs to be confident they can recoup as much of their loan amount as possible when selling the property.

For Buyers: While appraisals primarily protect lenders, they also benefit buyers by providing an objective assessment of the property's value. This helps ensure you're not overpaying for your new home.

For Cash Buyers: Even if you're buying with cash and don't have a lender requiring an appraisal, getting one is still recommended. It provides peace of mind that you're making a sound financial investment.

What Happens if the Appraisal Comes in Low?

If the appraised value is lower than the agreed-upon purchase price, you have several options:

1. Renegotiate the purchase price with the seller to match the appraised value
2. Pay the difference between the appraised value and purchase price in cash if needed 
3. Request a reconsideration of value (ROV) if you believe the appraisal contains errors or used inappropriate comparable properties resulting in a value inaccurately low
4. Walk away from the deal if the contract includes an appraisal contingency

Health and Safety Concerns in Appraisals

While appraisers primarily focus on value, they will note obvious health and safety issues that could affect the property's marketability or the lender's willingness to approve the loan. These might include:

• Unstable or missing railings - interior or exterior
• Significant foundation damage
• Evidence of termite activity (or Structural compromise from pests)
• Roof deterioration
• Electrical hazards
• Water damage or mold

When an appraiser identifies health and safety concerns, the lender may require these issues to be addressed before loan approval. Or they may require additional inspections such as a pest or foundation inspection to know how bad the damage is before making additional requirements for loan approval. Repairs might need to be completed before closing, or funds may be held in escrow to ensure completion. This is a great option when weather permits necessary repairs to be completed at a later time. In some cases, a lender may decline to issue a loan until a full inspection confirms the extent of the problems and necessary repairs are completed.

What is a Home Inspection?

A home inspection is a thorough examination of a property's physical structure and systems, conducted by a licensed or certified home inspector. The inspector's goal is to identify existing problems, potential issues, and safety concerns that could affect your decision to purchase the home.

Who Orders and Pays for the Inspection?

Unlike appraisals, home inspections are typically optional for conventional loans (though highly recommended). The buyer chooses and hires their own home inspector, giving them control over the process. The buyer also pays for the inspection, usually at the time of service.

Important Note: In competitive housing markets, a seller will often have a home inspection already completed and included in their disclosure package so a buyer is well informed prior to making an offer. However, it may be wise to hire your own home inspector who has your best interests at heart, rather than relying solely on an inspection ordered by the seller. We recommend consulting with your real estate agent about the timing and necessity of ordering your own inspection for your specific situation.

What Does a Home Inspector Evaluate?

A comprehensive home inspection examines:

Structural Components:

• Foundation and basement
• Walls, ceilings, and floors
• Roof structure and covering
• Attic and insulation

Major Systems:

• Electrical system and panels
• Plumbing and water heater
• HVAC (heating, ventilation, and air conditioning)
• Septic system or sewer connection

Exterior Features:

• Siding and exterior walls
• Windows and doors
• Gutters and downspouts
• Grading and drainage
• Decks, balconies, and porches
• Fences and gates
• Swimming pools and spas (if applicable)

Interior Features:

• Kitchen appliances
• Bathroom fixtures
• Ventilation systems
• Fireplaces and chimneys

Safety Issues:

• Smoke and carbon monoxide detectors
• Handrails and guardrails
• Potential hazards (lead paint, asbestos, mold)
• Pest infestations

The inspection typically takes 3-4 hours, and many buyers choose to attend, or have their real estate agent attend on their behalf, so they can ask questions and better understand the property's condition.

How Much Does an Inspection Cost?

Home inspection costs generally range from $300 to $500 for a single-family home, depending on:

• Size of the property
• Age of the home
• Location and local market rates
• Whether additional specialized inspections are needed (radon, mold, termite, etc.)

Why Inspections Matter

For Buyers: The inspection is your protection. It reveals the true condition of the property and helps you understand what repairs or maintenance you're signing up for. The inspection report gives you leverage to:

• Negotiate repairs with the seller
• Request a price reduction to account for needed repairs
• Request a credit at closing to handle repairs yourself
• Walk away from the deal if issues are too severe (if your contract includes an inspection contingency you will receive your earnest money deposit back)

What Sellers Should Know: If you're a seller, disclosures of known issues are legally required in most states and must be part of your disclosure packet. Some sellers choose to get a pre-listing inspection to address issues before putting the home on the market, but this comes with its own considerations that you should discuss with your real estate agent.

Regional Variations: What's Acceptable Where You Live

It's important to understand that what's considered acceptable in a home inspection can vary significantly based on your location and local conditions. For example:

• Earthquake-prone areas: Minor foundation cracks may be more acceptable in California or other seismically active regions than in areas where foundations typically remain pristine
  
  
• Coastal regions: Some corrosion or weather-related wear on exterior features might be considered normal
  
  
• Older housing markets: In areas with predominantly historic homes, certain outdated systems or materials may be more common and acceptable
  
  
• Climate considerations: What's standard for roofing, insulation, or HVAC systems varies greatly between, say, Arizona and Minnesota
  
  

Your real estate agent and home inspector should be familiar with local standards and can help you understand what's typical for your market.

Key Differences at a Glance

Appraisal vs. Inspection: Side-by-Side Comparison

Purpose

• Appraisal: Determines property value
• Inspection: Evaluates property condition

Primary Beneficiary

• Appraisal: Lender (though buyers can benefit too)
• Inspection: Buyer

Who Orders It

• Appraisal: Lender
• Inspection: Buyer (or seller in some cases) 

Who Performs It

• Appraisal: Licensed/certified appraiser
• Inspection: Licensed/certified home inspector

Required?

• Appraisal: Yes, for nearly all mortgage loans
• Inspection: Optional for most loans but highly recommended

Typical Cost (expect to pay more in high cost areas)

• Appraisal: $300-$550+ for single-family homes
• Inspection: $300-$500 for single-family homes

What's Examined

• Appraisal: Value factors (size, condition, location, comparable sales, replacement cost)
• Inspection: Structure, systems, safety issues, defects

Report Focus

• Appraisal: Fair market value estimate
• Inspection: Detailed condition assessment with recommendations

Timing

• Appraisal: Usually after offer acceptance, before closing
• Inspection: Usually within first week after offer acceptance

Common Scenarios: When Each Matters Most

Scenario 1: The Low Appraisal

You've offered $450,000 for your dream home, but the appraisal comes back at $430,000. Your lender will only  give you a loan based on a purchase price of $430,000. If you were planning on putting 20% down, that means your loan approval moved from $360,000 to $344,000*.

Your options:

• Negotiate with the seller to lower the price to $430,000
• Ask your lender if other loan programs are available to you requiring less than 20% down
• Come up with an additional $16,000 cash for your down payment
• Request a reconsideration of value if you believe the appraisal was inaccurate
• Walk away, but if your contract did not include an appraisal contingency, you can lose your deposit.

Scenario 2: The Inspection Reveals Major Issues

The home inspection uncovers a failing HVAC system (estimated $8,000 to replace) and significant roof damage (estimated $15,000 to repair).

Your options:

• Request that the seller make the repairs before closing
• Assuming the lender does not require repairs made before closing:
  
  • Negotiate a $23,000 reduction in purchase price
  • Request a credit at closing to handle repairs yourself, or for money to be held in escrow should the lender require
• Walk away if the issues are too extensive and your contract includes an inspection contingency, you will receive your deposit back

Scenario 3: Appraisal Identifies Health and Safety Concerns

The appraiser notes an unstable deck railing and signs of water damage in the basement. The lender flags these as health and safety concerns that must be addressed. Remember, just because you agreed to an “as is” property, doesn’t mean the lender did. 

What happens:

• The lender may require a general or specific inspection to determine the extent of the issues
• Repairs must be completed, or funds held in escrow until repairs are done
• The lender may decline the loan if issues are severe until they're resolved
• You and the seller may negotiate who will pay for repairs

Understanding Your Rights and Responsibilities

Your Right to Appraisal Information

According to the CFPB, for first-lien mortgages and certain higher-priced mortgage loans, lenders must:

• Inform you within three days of receiving your application that you're entitled to a free copy of appraisals
• Provide you with free copies of all appraisals and written valuations promptly, or at least three days before closing (a free copy does not mean the actual appraisal completed was free).

This transparency allows you to review how your property's value was determined and raise concerns if needed.

Challenging an Appraisal

If you believe an appraisal is inaccurate, you can request a reconsideration of value. Common grounds for challenging an appraisal include:

• Factual errors (incorrect square footage, number of bedrooms, etc.)
• Inappropriate comparable properties used
• Missing information about recent improvements or upgrades
• Evidence of appraisal bias
• Work with your lender and/or real estate agent for guidance

The CFPB and Department of Justice have made it clear that lenders cannot rely on discriminatory appraisals. If you suspect bias based on race, sex, or other protected characteristics, you should report this to your lender and may have legal recourse.

The Inspection Contingency

Most real estate purchase contracts include an inspection contingency, which gives you a specified period (often 7-10 days) to have the home inspected and either:

• Accept the property as-is (consult with your lender to make sure that’s acceptable if you need financing to complete the purchase)
• Negotiate repairs or credits with the seller
• Terminate the contract and receive your earnest money deposit back

This contingency is your safety net. Without it, you could be obligated to complete the purchase even if major problems are discovered.

Making Informed Decisions: Pros and Cons

Pros and Cons of Getting an Appraisal

Pros:

• Required by lenders, so not a choice for most buyers
• Provides an objective assessment of property value
• Protects you from overpaying
• Helps ensure the property is adequate collateral for the loan
• May reveal obvious health and safety issues

Cons:

• Costs $300-$550+ with no guarantee it matches your offer price
• Can delay or complicate closing if the value comes in low or if property condition concerns arise
• Limited in scope compared to a full inspection
• Focuses on value rather than condition details

Pros and Cons of Getting an Inspection

Pros:

• Reveals the true condition of the property
• Identifies potential safety hazards
• Provides negotiating leverage with the seller
• Helps you plan for future maintenance and repairs
• Gives you peace of mind about your investment
• Allows you to make an informed decision about the purchase

Cons:

• Costs $300-$500+ and is often optional (though highly recommended)
• May reveal issues that complicate or kill the deal
• Not required for conventional loans, so some buyers skip it
• Can be time-consuming (3-4+ hours onsite)

Special Considerations

Government-Backed Loans (FHA, VA, USDA)

If you're using an FHA, VA, or USDA loan, the appraisal requirements are more stringent:

• FHA loans: The appraisal includes a property inspection to ensure the home meets HUD's minimum property standards for safety and livability
• VA loans: The appraisal includes specific requirements to ensure the property is safe and sanitary for a veteran's occupancy
• USDA loans: Similar safety and structural standards apply

These government-backed appraisals are more thorough than conventional appraisals and may overlap somewhat with what a home inspection would cover. However, a separate home inspection is still recommended to get a complete picture of the property's condition.

The "Flipped" Property Rule

If you're buying a home that was recently purchased and resold (flipped) within a short timeframe, and you're getting a higher-priced mortgage loan, federal rules may require a second appraisal. This protects buyers from artificially inflated prices on properties that haven't been substantially improved.

Cash Purchases

If you're buying with cash and don't need a mortgage, you technically don't need an appraisal or inspection. However, both are still highly recommended:

• An appraisal confirms you're paying a fair price
• An inspection reveals what you're truly buying and what repairs you'll face

Don't skip these critical assessments just because you can.

Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

Pitfall #1: Waiving the Inspection in a Competitive Market

In hot real estate markets, some buyers waive the inspection contingency to make their offer more attractive. This is extremely risky. If you must waive the contingency to compete, consider:

• Getting a pre-offer inspection (if the seller allows it)
• Building a substantial repair fund into your budget
• Having a thorough discussion with your agent about the risks

Pitfall #2: Assuming the Appraisal Checks for Safety Issues

While appraisers note obvious problems, their primary focus is value, not safety. Don't assume that a successful appraisal means the home is in good condition. Always get a separate inspection.

Pitfall #3: Not Reviewing the Appraisal Carefully

When you receive your appraisal, review it thoroughly for:

• Factual errors (wrong square footage, incorrect number of rooms, etc.)
• Inappropriate comparable properties
• Missing information about improvements or upgrades

If you spot errors, request a reconsideration of value promptly.

Pitfall #4: Accepting the Inspection Report Without Questions

The inspection report can be overwhelming, often listing dozens of items. Don't panic. Attend the inspection if possible and ask the inspector:

• Which issues are urgent safety concerns?
• Which issues are routine maintenance?
• What's the estimated lifespan of major systems?
• What should be addressed immediately vs. long-term?

Your inspector can help you prioritize and understand what really matters.

Pitfall #5: Not Confirming Appraisal Review

Before getting too far ahead of yourself, confirm that the appraisal has been reviewed by an underwriter and accepted by the lender. Sometimes issues flagged in the appraisal require follow-up, clarification, or additional documentation. Don't assume everything is fine until you receive confirmation from your lender.

Your Action Plan: Navigating Both Processes Successfully

When Your Offer is Accepted:

1. Within 24-48 hours: Schedule your home inspection (assuming you're including an inspection contingency). Your lender will order your appraisal at a cost paid by you, so if you want to review the inspection first, tell the lender to hold off on ordering the appraisal. Be aware this may delay closing depending on your contractual closing timeframe.
   
   
2. Within 5-7 days: Complete the home inspection and receive the report
   
   
3. Within 7-10 days (or per your contract terms):
   
   
   
   1. Review the inspection report carefully
   2. Consult with your real estate agent about any issues
   3. Decide whether to request repairs, credits, or price reductions
   4. Submit any requests to the seller
4. 1-2 weeks after appraisal is ordered: Receive the appraisal report
   
   
5. Upon receiving the appraisal:
   
   
   
   1. Review for accuracy
   2. Confirm the value meets or exceeds your offer price
   3. Request reconsideration of value if needed
   4. Work with your lender to address any health and safety concerns noted
6. Throughout the process: Stay in close communication with your real estate agent, lender, and other professionals
   
   

Working with Your Real Estate Agent

Throughout both the appraisal and inspection processes, your real estate agent is your advocate and guide. They can:

• Recommend reputable home inspectors
• Help you interpret inspection findings and prioritize concerns
• Negotiate with the seller on your behalf for repairs or credits
• Guide you through appraisal challenges
• Advise you on market-specific considerations
• Help you make informed decisions that protect your interests

Never hesitate to ask your agent questions or voice concerns. They're there to help you navigate these complex processes successfully.

The Bottom Line

While home appraisals and home inspections are distinctly different—one assessing value for the lender, the other assessing condition for you—both are critical components of a successful home purchase. The appraisal ensures you're not borrowing more than the property is worth, while the inspection ensures you're not buying more problems than you bargained for.

Think of it this way: the appraisal tells you what you're paying, and the inspection tells you what you're getting. Together, they provide the complete picture you need to make one of the biggest financial decisions of your life with confidence.

As you navigate the homebuying process, remember that knowledge is your best protection. Take the time to understand both assessments, review all reports carefully, ask questions, and work closely with your real estate agent and lender. Your diligence now can save you from costly surprises down the road.

At Multiply Mortgage, we're committed to helping you understand every step of the homebuying process. If you have questions about appraisals, inspections, or any other aspect of securing your mortgage, our team of expert loan advisors is here to help. Contact us today to learn more about how we can support your homeownership journey.

Disclaimer: This article provides general educational information about home appraisals and inspections. Every real estate transaction is unique, and standards can vary by location, loan type, and individual circumstances. Always consult with your real estate agent, lender, and other qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation. The information provided is accurate as of the publication date and may be subject to change.

‍